First Chicago Insurance Company – Reviews, Price & Phone Number

5/5 - (2 votes)

On December 14, 1920, the company was formed as the Chicago Ice Producers Mutual Liability Company. It was initially created in the form of a mutual insurance firm. The company’s purpose was to protect the people who belong to Chicago District Ice Association. Chicago District Ice Association for general liability, workers compensation, public liability for wagons and horses, and commercial vehicles insurance.

 Association members contributed the $26,225 required to begin insurance operations at its founding. The company was given licenses to operate within three states: States in Illinois, Indiana, and Wisconsin, and they are maintained to this day. In the early 1930s, the business began to insure private automobiles of employees and owners of Ice companies.

The company later expanded to include people referred by the company’s policyholders. Chicago Mutual Liability Company was renamed in 1961. Through the 1970s and the 1980s, the company shifted from its initial focus of an insurance company for commercial lines to becoming an auto insurance company. In 1994, at the close of the Board of Directors decided to remove all Worker’s Compensation and general liability lines and focus on the commercial and personal auto business lines.

In the year 1991, the Board of Directors decided to modify the distribution method of the company by moving away from direct writing and partnering together with an independent producer. The company had seen the growth of its natural writer and required a new approach. The company’s name was changed in 1996, changing it to Chicago Mutual Insurance Company.

 In 2006, the business was changed from a mutual type of governance to a stock-based company. It was rebranded as First Chicago Insurance Company and later became part of J & P Holdings, Inc. The company’s primary focus is innovation as the 100th anniversary of the company’s founding nears. Management is constantly looking for opportunities that will benefit our current policyholders and aid in the company’s success and growth.

First, Chicago may not be the most well-known insurance provider, but you may need to inquire about an estimate if you’re within one of seven states offering individual automobile insurance. The coverage provided by the company is essential, but it can be an ideal choice for drivers who don’t need or want an extremely personalized policy.

First Chicago Insurance Company

First Chicago Insurance company is a regional insurance provider that operates in the Midwest and provides commercial auto, personal auto, and artisan liability insurance. It’s a wholly-owned subsidiary of J & P Holdings, Inc. It has been in operation since 1920. First, Chicago Insurance initially provided insurance to Chicago’s District Ice Association’s wagons, horses, and horses. The company was subsequently named Chicago Ice Producers Mutual Liability Company. Since then, the company has expanded to provide personal and commercial insurance throughout the Midwest across Indiana, Illinois, and Indiana and private auto insurance in Wisconsin. An independent agent writes policies for insurance.

At first, First Chicago Insurance was a mutual insurance company, but it changed to a stock corporation in 2006. The corporate headquarters are located within Bedford Park, Illinois. First, Chicago Insurance has a partnership with’s insurance comparison site, Throughout the 100 years of its existence, the company has had only five presidents. Led the company. The present chief executive Michael Rosenstein is the current president. Michael Rosenstein.

First Chicago Insurance Reviews

Below are some of the First Chicago Insurance Reviews:

First, Chicago Insurance is one of the most popular insurance companies in the United States. They offer a wide variety of insurance products, including auto, home, life, and health insurance. Their products are affordable, and they have an excellent reputation for customer service.

First, Chicago Insurance reviews are overwhelmingly positive. Policyholders praise the company for its low rates, comprehensive coverage options, and helpful customer service representatives. Many customers report that they have been with First Chicago Insurance for years and have never had a problem with claims or payments.

Overall, First Chicago Insurance reviews is a highly-rated company that offers affordable insurance products with great customer service. If you are looking for an insurer, First Chicago should be at the top of your list.

Financial Strength Ratings

First, Chicago Insurance received an upgraded “B” rating from the insurance rating company AM Best. This rating was issued on November 20, 2021. The company’s credit rating was simultaneously changed from “bb” to “bb-.” AM Best listed the rating upgrade’s reason as “adequate operating performance, limited business profile, and marginal enterprise risk management (ERM). “1

Better Business Bureau Rating

First Chicago Insurance has been certified by the Better Business Bureau for 30 years and is accredited with been awarded an “A+” rating. It has received a total rating that is 1.02 out of five stars. There are 50 reviews from customers. There are 108 complaints from customers included, and 54 were resolved within the past year. All complaints have been closed.

First Chicago Insurance Phone Number

Below is the First Chicago Insurance Phone Number:

+1 708-552-4400

First Chicago Insurance Company Address

Below are the First Chicago insurance locations, or you can say First Chicago Insurance Company Address

5401 College Blvd # 201, Leawood, KS 66211, United States (Source)

Here are a few frequently asked questions to help you locate the city’s most suitable renter’s insurance policy.


What is the average cost of the renters’ insurance in Chicago?

Renters’ insurance for Chicago is $124 annually, about 10 dollars per month.

What is the most affordable renter’s insurance provider in Chicago?

The insurance companies with the lowest prices in Chicago based on the average rate include Lemonade ($60 annually) and State Farm ($89 per year).

What is the most reliable renter’s insurance provider in Chicago?

According to Money Geek’s research Based on Money Geek’s study, the most effective renters insurance company for renters in Chicago in Chicago is USAA. The best choice for renters that cannot qualify to be eligible for USAA policy is State Farm.

Do I need renters’ insurance in Chicago?

Chicago residents are not legally required to purchase renters’ insurance; however, your landlord might need the insurance. Money Geek also suggests renters’ insurance as an affordable method to safeguard your personal belongings.

Here are some commonly asked questions that will help you find the best renters insurance policy in the city.

Does First Chicago Insurance have renters’ insurance?

Yes, In Chicago, we refer to it as apartment insurance. The actual name is renters’ insurance, which protects your possessions such as TVs, computers, bicycles, electronics, furniture, and clothing. Outside and inside your condominium, apartment, or rental home.

It may also cover items stored in the garage of your apartment or storage closet or on your deck or patio. Insurance coverage for renters extends to personal possessions that you keep in your vehicle. If your laptop gets stolen from your car is likely to be protected, and if your bike is taken when you’re working, It’s probably protected.

Renters’ insurance Chicago policy will pay for damage to property, injuries, and liability claims brought against you and the loss of rental income due to the losses that result from the covered claims. This policy can help safeguard your furnishings, furniture, and property from liability and can even compensate you for rent lost in the event of losses due to insured claims.


Who is the oldest insurance company?

Hamburger Feuerkasse (English: Hamburg Fire Office) is the first official fire insurance company globally and is the oldest insurance firm accessible to the general public. It was founded in 1676.

How many insurance companies are in Chicago?

In Chicago, there are 61 insurance companies worth knowing.

Who is the number 1 insurance company in America?

In the United States, State Farm is the leading insurance coverage provider.


First Chicago Insurance Company operates as an insurance firm. The company offers insurance for property and casualty, which includes commercial and personal auto insurance and artisan-general liability coverage options. First, Chicago Insurance serves customers throughout Indiana and Illinois. States that have Illinois in addition to Indiana.

Leave a Comment